Performance improvement plans

Handed a performance improvement plan? Read this before you respond.

A performance improvement plan (PIP) is a formal document that sets out what your employer says you need to improve, and by when. Sometimes it's a genuine attempt to help. Sometimes it's the first step in getting you out. How you respond in the first few days matters in both cases.

Genuine PIP or push-out?

Telling these apart is the most important thing you can do early. Here are the tells I look for.

More likely genuine

  • Specific, measurable targets you can actually meet in the time given.
  • Clear examples of what went wrong, and what good looks like.
  • Real support: coaching, resources, regular check-ins that happen.
  • It follows a history of honest feedback, not years of good reviews.

More likely a push-out

  • Vague criticism with no examples, or targets that can't be hit together.
  • Goals that change during the plan, or a deadline that is very short.
  • It arrives after good reviews, a restructure, a pay rise or a change in your circumstances.
  • HR is present from the start, and the language is about "last chance" or "serious concerns".
  • You're offered a way out (a settlement or a "clean exit") early on or soon after.

Rules differ by country. In some places, an employer is expected to give a real chance to improve before dismissing for performance. In others, such as much of the US, no process is required at all, and a PIP can simply be a paper trail. Either way, the detail of the plan tells you a lot.

What to do in the first days

  1. Take a breath and don't react in the meeting. You can say you'd like time to read it.
  2. If you're asked to sign, check whether you're acknowledging receipt or agreeing with the contents. Acknowledging receipt is usually fine. Agreeing that the criticism is fair is not, and you can note that you disagree.
  3. Ask for specifics in writing: what exactly was missed, how it is measured and what support will be provided.
  4. Reply in writing, calmly and factually. Put your own account on the record without arguing.
  5. Keep dated notes of every meeting, and keep copies of your reviews, targets and praise that you are entitled to hold.
  6. Keep doing your job well, and keep discussions about your options away from work systems.
  7. Don't resign. Think first about what you'd want from an exit, such as severance, a reference, timing and the wording of the departure.

A PIP is also a negotiation moment

Many employers would rather agree an exit than see a plan through. If a settlement is on offer, the first number is rarely the last. Because the plan is in motion, you also have more room than you might think, but that room shrinks the longer you wait. If you are being pushed out, see the page on being pushed out of your role.

How I help

I read the plan and what led up to it, tell you honestly whether it looks genuine or like a push-out, help you respond in writing, and if it comes to an exit, negotiate it with you. I'm an independent consultant, not a law firm, so where legal advice or sign-off is needed I'll say so and point you to qualified counsel.

Common questions

Can I be dismissed during a PIP?

It depends on your country and your contract. In some places the employer is expected to let the plan run and give you a real chance. In others, such as much of the US, it can end at any time. Check your contract and get local advice.

Should I resign if I get a PIP?

Usually not. Resigning can cost you severance and unemployment benefits and removes your leverage. Get advice first, then decide.

Do PIPs always end in dismissal?

No. Some end with the person staying. But when a plan arrives after good reviews, or has targets that can't realistically be met, it often ends in an exit, which is why it pays to prepare for that early.

Can you help if I already have a PIP?

Yes. That's one of the most common times people get in touch. Send me the plan and what has happened and I'll tell you what I see.

Talk to me before it goes any further.

I typically reply within one working day. The first conversation is free.

Book a free call

Or write to hello@thresholdadvisory.io

← Back to the Threshold Advisory homepage